I just bought a 3 x 12 x 18 granite surface plate from Enco, shop grade. They had it on sale plus free shipping($70. total). I am going to build a metal stand and plan on support only at the perimeter. The question , is this enough support or do I need center support?
Surface plate stand
Collapse
X
-
There is a standard mounting convention for surface plates that is a 3 point suspension. Here's a link to the Starrett site, look at question #12 for info: http://www.tru-stone.com/pages/faq.asp#question12
Comment
-
-
The 3 point mounting system calculation is called "airy points." Here's a thread where I made a crude stand that works very well. http://bbs.homeshopmachinist.net/thr...ght=AIRY+POINTMilton
"Accuracy is the sum total of your compensating mistakes."
"The thing I hate about an argument is that it always interrupts a discussion." G. K. Chesterton
Comment
-
-
The Airy points are extremely close to 5/9ths of the overall length of the plate (but centered). The distance of Airy points can be important because it is such that when a piece is supported by them it is at minimal flex opposed to any other point configuration.
Will it matter with a thick B grade shop plate? No.
Comment
-
-
More important, they are the points where the plate was supported during it's manufacturer. So when the plate is supported at those points, any flexing will be the same as when it was made and tested so the plate will be at it's flattest.
Now, if you have a plate that is supported in another manner, and it is resurfaced while supported that manner, then it will be at it's flattest when it is supported in that, alternate manner.
The key here is consistency.
Originally posted by Andre3127 View PostThe Airy points are extremely close to 5/9ths of the overall length of the plate (but centered). The distance of Airy points can be important because it is such that when a piece is supported by them it is at minimal flex opposed to any other point configuration.
Will it matter with a thick B grade shop plate? No.Paul A.
s
Golden Triangle, SE Texas
And if you look REAL close at an analog signal,
You will find that it has discrete steps.
Comment
-
-
The size of these "points" would depend on the size of the plate. For a relatively small plate, 2 feet and under, about one inch (diameter or square) would be nice. For larger plates, you are going to need larger support pads. I would use a hard rubber or similar material.
I have a small, 9" x 12", shop grade plate and I doubt that the points are very important. I just have it on a piece of that foam shelf liner material to distribute the weight over the whole bottom surface. It does not have any points marked on it's bottom.
Originally posted by Andre3127 View PostAny type of furniture felt or rubber pads will do nicely.Paul A.
s
Golden Triangle, SE Texas
And if you look REAL close at an analog signal,
You will find that it has discrete steps.
Comment
-
-
It's 3" thick, and only 12x18" You could support it at one end only and suspend the other in mid air and not be able to detect any sort of practical or measurable difference with typical home shop equipment. Build whatever kind of stand you want. Perimeter support only will be totally fine on a plate of that size.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by theGallery View PostThanks for the information and comments. I think I now have a plan that is probably way over kill for a shop grade plate in a home hobby machine shop. Out of curiosity I spent about a half hour researching the web for commercial stands and not a single one mentioned a three point support.located in Toronto Ontario
Comment
-
Comment