Originally posted by Sparky_NY
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Fusion 360 new pricing
Collapse
X
-
Autodesk have a track record of moving the goal posts on customers, I wouldn't touch one of their products as their long term goal always seems to emerge as monetising customers to a greater extent than previously promised.If you benefit from the Dunning-Kruger Effect you may not even know it ;-)
Comment
-
Pushed in that direction by a client, I've got up to speed quickly with Fusion 360 (helps to have become proficient with 3 other systems in the past, most recently Solidworks) and have been using nearly all its features, and nearly exclusively, since March 2019. I've been operating under the free offer for startups making under $100k/yr since my business is exactly that - a spinoff/startup trying to commercialize some fairly esoteric intellectual property developed as part of a university research grant.
With this recent re-definition of the hobby/startup offers, I had to re-apply and re-qualify for the startup offer. I submitted my info again and got a call from F-360 a couple of weeks ago telling me they are not approving me for startup status based on their review of my website, which they see as "consulting" not a "startup." I led the nice man through the website, pointed out exactly what the business was about, he said he understood and said he would make notes and refer the case back to the approval folks. I've heard nothing since. As far as I know, I will lose my Fusion 360 startup account on November 1. I've already started saving my projects in STEP and IGES formats to my local computer.
I have a distinct feeling that instead of just my website they went through the data and projects I have stored on their cloud, which include a lot of sample and practice "projects" (quite a few from the Fusion 360 online resources) that I worked through as I was developing proficiency with their tools, as well as a few personal projects. Looking at all of that, it looks like I do a lot more than what my website talks about. It would be quite ironic if I lost my startup status simply because I was trying to learn to use their tools.
It seems that if I want to continue to use Fusion 360 I'll have to call them back and beg them to re-assess my startup application, change to the hobby version (losing phone/email support, team collaboration and commercial translators, but I use the last two almost daily) or bite the bullet and start paying for the full commercial version. I guess it's a good thing that it's on sale now for 37% off, and the nice man on the phone swore up and down it'll never be more for me than $310/yr... at least until they "redefine" something and change the rules again. One thing that sucks is that FEA (Fusion 360 calls it "simulation" and I use it a lot) is free on the cloud for startups but pay-as-you-go for the commercial version via "cloud credits."SE MI, USA
Comment
-
Originally posted by DrMike View PostPushed in that direction by a client, I've got up to speed quickly with Fusion 360 (helps to have become proficient with 3 other systems in the past, most recently Solidworks) and have been using nearly all its features, and nearly exclusively, since March 2019. I've been operating under the free offer for startups making under $100k/yr since my business is exactly that - a spinoff/startup trying to commercialize some fairly esoteric intellectual property developed as part of a university research grant.
With this recent re-definition of the hobby/startup offers, I had to re-apply and re-qualify for the startup offer. I submitted my info again and got a call from F-360 a couple of weeks ago telling me they are not approving me for startup status based on their review of my website, which they see as "consulting" not a "startup." I led the nice man through the website, pointed out exactly what the business was about, he said he understood and said he would make notes and refer the case back to the approval folks. I've heard nothing since. As far as I know, I will lose my Fusion 360 startup account on November 1. I've already started saving my projects in STEP and IGES formats to my local computer.
I have a distinct feeling that instead of just my website they went through the data and projects I have stored on their cloud, which include a lot of sample and practice "projects" (quite a few from the Fusion 360 online resources) that I worked through as I was developing proficiency with their tools, as well as a few personal projects. Looking at all of that, it looks like I do a lot more than what my website talks about. It would be quite ironic if I lost my startup status simply because I was trying to learn to use their tools.
It seems that if I want to continue to use Fusion 360 I'll have to call them back and beg them to re-assess my startup application, change to the hobby version (losing phone/email support, team collaboration and commercial translators, but I use the last two almost daily) or bite the bullet and start paying for the full commercial version. I guess it's a good thing that it's on sale now for 37% off, and the nice man on the phone swore up and down it'll never be more for me than $310/yr... at least until they "redefine" something and change the rules again. One thing that sucks is that FEA (Fusion 360 calls it "simulation" and I use it a lot) is free on the cloud for startups but pay-as-you-go for the commercial version via "cloud credits."Location: The Black Forest in Germany
How to become a millionaire: Start out with 10 million and take up machining as a hobby!
Comment
-
"Just pony up and get on with it... Use your time on profitable projects. Increase income."
I've never thought of business in such clear, simple and easily obtainable goals.
I've just been wasting my time and money dicking around instead of increasing income.
Thank you, Mr. Forest, for showing me the light and clearing my path forward.
SE MI, USA
Comment
-
Originally posted by DrMike View Post"Just pony up and get on with it... Use your time on profitable projects. Increase income."
I've never thought of business in such clear, simple and easily obtainable goals.
I've just been wasting my time and money dicking around instead of increasing income.
Thank you, Mr. Forest, for showing me the light and clearing my path forward.I don't think I said anything about easily obtainable......I just said get on with it.
Location: The Black Forest in Germany
How to become a millionaire: Start out with 10 million and take up machining as a hobby!
Comment
-
Come renew time for hobbyist and startup the unlimited cloud access for rendering and generative design studies will be gone (for all licenses).
I would no longer meet startup requirements at next renew time so I went for the $310 standalone as well, it's a bargain for the quality.and power, besides that I now feel free to complain
Comment
-
$300 a year is dirt cheap - even for a hobby. I'm not that old but I remember the insane pricing on CAD software even 10 years ago. Aside from a few players most mid range CAD software started at $2000 per seat plus yearly subscription fees. This didn't include CAM / FEA etc. You want 3 / 4 axis CAM? Pony up.
I'm not a huge Autodesk cheerleader. In fact I prefer Solidworks and OnShape (OnShape is now PTC - Jon Hirschtick and Co pulled the same stunt they did with Solidworks when they sold it to Dassault). But Solidworks doesn't innovate anymore and just takes your money and redistributes to shareholders. At least Autodesk decided to innovate this time around.
Comment
-
Originally posted by pinstripe View Post
That's the problem. They aren't charging what it's worth. I'm sure the pricing will always be reasonable for business customers, but it could get steep for a hobbyist.
Comment
-
And meanwhile, both versions of Alibre will work and stay legitimate even if you stop paying annual support...... although you would no longer get updates.
Not true of F 360, nor of Solidworks. F 360 is a rent-a-program, and SW terminates the license if you stop paying. (it might work still, but is not legit, and might get "killed" at any time.)Last edited by J Tiers; 10-30-2019, 06:55 PM.CNC machines only go through the motions.
Ideas expressed may be mine, or from anyone else in the universe.
Not responsible for clerical errors. Or those made by lay people either.
Number formats and units may be chosen at random depending on what day it is.
I reserve the right to use a number system with any integer base without prior notice.
Generalizations are understood to be "often" true, but not true in every case.
Comment
-
And meanwhile, both versions of Alibre will work and stay legitimate even if you stop paying annual support...... although you would no longer get updates.
Not true of F 360, nor of Solidworks. F 360 is a rent-a-program, and SW terminates the license if you stop paying. (it might work still, but is not legit, and might get "killed" at any time.)
Comment
-
Originally posted by pinstripe View Post
, but it could get steep for a hobbyist.The shortest distance between two points is a circle of infinite diameter.
Bluewater Model Engineering Society at https://sites.google.com/site/bluewatermes/
Southwestern Ontario. Canada
Comment
-
Originally posted by loose nut View PostWhat would be the point, hobbyists are not going to pay much...
Hobbyists will be collateral damage in Autodesk's pursuit of maximizing profits. To be clear, I have no problem with them chasing a profit. That is what they should do for their shareholders. It looks like a great package, but it's currently underpriced relative to the competition. It's also eating into the sales of their more expensive products to some extent.
Comment
Comment