OT- To All Who Post on HSM - Assistance to our Continued Forum Use IMHO

[Dan Dubeau]

If anything this thread has highlighted the fact that many of use this board in different ways, and for different purposes. Some even for machining related activities and discussions .

[JRouche]

Much of the Mega Thread content is similar to the FacePlant members that constantly post their location or what their eating, etc.

Hey, I found a shoe. Ill put it on JR

Found this nice cheeseburger joint here in Southern California!! (my house ) JR

[reggie_obe]

Much of the Mega Thread content is similar to the FacePlant members that constantly post their location or what their eating, etc.

[Cenedd]

Should be obvious that there are not even any squirt guns.................

Hey, you leave our squirt guns out of this..... that's the highest we're allowed to escalate things this side of the pond!

[J Tiers]

Bah. I was hoping for a challenge for pistols at dawn.

-js

International over-reaction....... read the original post of the sub-thread...... where I agree with one of the points (which I had actually made myself in at least one prior post). Should be obvious that there are not even any squirt guns.................

[Jim Stewart]

Bah. I was hoping for a challenge for pistols at dawn.

-js

[J Tiers]

That is always the problem with casual text-based communication - mainly forums but also chat, SMS etc. It's so easy to read something into the way someone's written something, get all huffy about it and it just escalates from there. Well, since we both agree we should stop fighting and have a socially distanced beer. 4,000 miles should be enough for this new variant, right?!

I already did.... there was no fight!

[Cenedd]

But, it WAS amusing to realize just how the post could be interpreted!

That is always the problem with casual text-based communication - mainly forums but also chat, SMS etc. It's so easy to read something into the way someone's written something, get all huffy about it and it just escalates from there. Well, since we both agree we should stop fighting and have a socially distanced beer. 4,000 miles should be enough for this new variant, right?!

[J Tiers]

I wasn't disagreeing with you Jerry, nor saying that said threads MUST be kept; just explaining what value I find in them. I'm easy with whatever gets decided but I suspect George knows that whatever is done (and I'm including "nothing" as a choice here), you won't please everyone.

I know, I'm actually "kinda" agreeing with YOU!

The "no big whoop" point is a very good one.

But, it WAS amusing to realize just how the post could be interpreted!

[Cenedd]

I wasn't disagreeing with you Jerry, nor saying that said threads MUST be kept; just explaining what value I find in them. I'm easy with whatever gets decided but I suspect George knows that whatever is done (and I'm including "nothing" as a choice here), you won't please everyone.

[J Tiers]

Hi guys. At the risk of chiming in when I should probably know better and keep my mouth shut, there's another thing the mega threads are good for. Whilst I agree that some content has been hidden and some could better be it's own thread, I'm subscribed to those threads - and did read through them all slowly for interest partly for machining and partly as Baz said for the non-machining stuff. Every day or so I get an email notification and catch up on something that's going on. There is a social element to it but also a continuity element - I don't regularly have much time to go looking for new threads but a post in a mega thread will often pull me back in. If it then links to a project thread, I might well subscribe to that and once in a while have something worth adding.
Some things are too small for their own "Look, I made a thingy" thread and would, I suspect get some equivalent of "Yeah? Big whoop!". These sort of threads do provide that and sometimes it sparks interest beyond "Oh, nice". At that point it might be best broken off into a separate thread...but somebody would have to proactively do that task and instead it often runs on.

TLDR: Mega threads have some value. The social element, advertising (by means of email notification) a new project thread worth checking out, small posts that get more interest than anticipated.

Can't see a problem splitting off to a new one yearly though. Wouldn't have a problem with someone moderating them to split off chunks into separate threads if necessary - the question would be, who has time and would be accepted?

heh.....

What you really are saying, even if you don't quite realize it, is that "the mega thread has become the forum".

Instead of checking the forum, you check the mega thread.

So, in a sense, you are totally agreeing with, and providing an example of, the very reason why some of us don;t like them.


As for the "no big whoop" projects, I totally agree. If they could be restricted to that, they would be totally fine with me. That's sort of difficult, and nobody at VP has time for it.

Perhaps there SHOULD be one....Just ONE, that is titled "What tiny project did you do today?"

[nickel-city-fab]

This thread started out looking for a solution to a problem that doesn't exist.
It has evolved into a "what's my gripe".

Left to our own devices, we are no different than the kids in "Lord of the Flies".

Most of the places where I've worked thought it was a training manual.

[Cenedd]

Hi guys. At the risk of chiming in when I should probably know better and keep my mouth shut, there's another thing the mega threads are good for. Whilst I agree that some content has been hidden and some could better be it's own thread, I'm subscribed to those threads - and did read through them all slowly for interest partly for machining and partly as Baz said for the non-machining stuff. Every day or so I get an email notification and catch up on something that's going on. There is a social element to it but also a continuity element - I don't regularly have much time to go looking for new threads but a post in a mega thread will often pull me back in. If it then links to a project thread, I might well subscribe to that and once in a while have something worth adding.
Some things are too small for their own "Look, I made a thingy" thread and would, I suspect get some equivalent of "Yeah? Big whoop!". These sort of threads do provide that and sometimes it sparks interest beyond "Oh, nice". At that point it might be best broken off into a separate thread...but somebody would have to proactively do that task and instead it often runs on.

TLDR: Mega threads have some value. The social element, advertising (by means of email notification) a new project thread worth checking out, small posts that get more interest than anticipated.

Can't see a problem splitting off to a new one yearly though. Wouldn't have a problem with someone moderating them to split off chunks into separate threads if necessary - the question would be, who has time and would be accepted?

[JRouche]

Yeah folks! Did you know Green Bay and thye Bears were playing tonight? No? Oh well. JI love them both so it is difficult. R

[CalM]

This thread started out looking for a solution to a problem that doesn't exist.
It has evolved into a "what's my gripe".

Left to our own devices, we are no different than the kids in "Lord of the Flies".