Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Is countertop granite flat enough for surface plate?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Is countertop granite flat enough for surface plate?

    The header says it. We'll have some left over from the kitchen remodel and I hate to just toss it since I paid for it . I don't need inspection room accuracy, plus or minus .001 is more than good enough for what I do. THANKS!

  • #2
    measure it ... if its good its good

    a piece of float glass and some blue will tell you

    Comment


    • #3
      An old gent I knew who built absolutely beautiful model steam engines used a piece of busted-off granite facing veneer from an old store front for his surface plate. ("It drops off about three thou towards that corner, but I allow for it.") So I expect a piece of granite countertop will be at least that good, and at least that usable.

      But the only way to tell, for sure, is to measure the piece of granite you have and see what it's like. Put a dial indicator on a surface gage and sweep it across the surface in several directions.

      And let us know what you find. I'm curious.
      ----------
      Try to make a living, not a killing. -- Utah Phillips
      Don't believe everything you know. -- Bumper sticker
      Everybody is ignorant, only on different subjects. -- Will Rogers
      There are lots of people who mistake their imagination for their memory. - Josh Billings
      Law of Logical Argument - Anything is possible if you don't know what you are talking about.
      Don't own anything you have to feed or paint. - Hood River Blackie

      Comment


      • #4
        I bought a 12" square of black granite at Home Depot some time back and used it with great success for a lot of projects. I have a granite surface plate now but I still use this one for sanding and quick checks of non-critical parts.

        You can easily check the flatness by placing the tiles face to face. Any two that resist spinning (surface tension) are good fits to each other. If a third is found that is also a good fit you probably have found as good a set as exists in the store. The store floor people will look at you oddly.

        Comment


        • #5
          The Enco 12x18, Grade B surface plate is $24.95 with free shipping:

          http://www.use-enco.com/CGI/INSRIT?P...PMAKA=640-0120
          "Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did."

          Comment


          • #6
            Unfortunately, I believe they ship granite plates by truck now, so I don't think you can get the free shipping deal on them.
            Cheers,

            Frank Ford
            HomeShopTech

            Comment


            • #7
              Ijust received a 12x18 surface plate from enco, free shipping, delivered to my door by ups.

              bones

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by Frank Ford
                Unfortunately, I believe they ship granite plates by truck now, so I don't think you can get the free shipping deal on them.
                Enco may have changed its policy but I purchased a 12x18 a few months back at the $24-$26 price and it came with free shipping via UPS or FedEX, forget which.
                Bob

                Comment


                • #9
                  The two smallest sizes of surface plate are shippable by truck. Highly reccomend using the free UPS, there are still a few days left for a 25 dollar minimum.

                  If there is a Woodcraft store near you you can do that as well, They sell 9x12 grade B, as some woodworking tools need careful alignment aided by a reference..

                  Wish there was such a thing as "MetalCraft" sort of is in LMS but we could use some more variety.

                  It depends on what you consider a surface plate. Granite is good because it does not expand too much when heated, is abrasion resistant and cannot get burs, which mean that good counter top may be useable for less precise stuff such as marking.

                  Scraping and toolmaking == NO! NOT PRECISE ENOUGH!

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    You have to check the piece you get. I have a sink cutout from a granite counter. Nice and smooth but nowhere near flat. Out at least 20 thou from corner to corner. Over a small area, it's fairly flat. Too thin for a real surface plate. On the plus side, mine is 20 by 30 inches and I can lift it.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Ironically this has just come up tonight on a UK forum.
                      I have taken the liberty of copy and pasting the post from a well know and respected UK member Jim Petagrid and all the following is Jim's work.


                      *****************

                      Having recently aquired a 6" optical flat I thought it would be
                      interesting to checkout the granite placemats and chopping boards
                      now stocked by the supermarkets. These are 15 to 20mm thick and
                      small enough and light enough to be kept in a drawer when not in
                      use.
                      Although the working surface is polished, it is only
                      polished sufficiently to give a shine. There's severe "orange
                      peel" surface disturbance - not good enough for optical
                      interferometry checks. However the surface is ideal for the
                      capillary/surface tension method.

                      http://xs434.xs.to/xs434/08011/granite_1a910.jpg

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/granite_1b902.jpg

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/granite_2a522.jpg

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/granite_2b880.jpg

                      Show the test results on two 15mm thick placemats. The 6"
                      flat was supported at the top end with an 0.005" shim to give an
                      airgap slope of about 5/6000. The equal thickness capillary
                      edge displays a 6000/5 amplification of the flatness error -
                      approx 1" per 0.001" Each plate was tested at 0deg and 90deg and
                      showed errors of less than 0.0004".

                      The tests were repeated on a 300 x 400 x 15mm chopping board.

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/chop_board_0.005925.jpg

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/chop_...0_0.005344.jpg

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/chop_board_0.001674.jpg

                      The first two show the 0deg and 90deg results The third is a
                      repeat of the 90deg result but with an 0.001" shim.

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/plgla...1_x_2in878.jpg

                      Is the result using an 0.001" slope on a 12" length of 2" x
                      1/2" plate glass (ex shop window display shelf)

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/splatemeths0.005256.jpg

                      Is an 0.005" slope test on a 12" x 18" surface plate. Although
                      the lower faint capillary edge is fairly visible by eye, the
                      contrast is too low for satisfactory photography. Both Meths and
                      ispropanol (rubbing alcohol) gave similar results but a marking
                      out fluid which appears to be heavily dyed alcohol gave
                      excellent contrast. The snag is that the higher viscosity
                      results in a long settling time.

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/splatemkgbu0.005571.jpg

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/splate0.001start328.jpg

                      http://xs134.xs.to/xs134/08011/splate0.001finish758.jpg

                      The fist JPG is an 0.005" slope test. The second shows the
                      beginning of an 0.001" slope test. the third is the result
                      1/2hour later. The results show up the comparative roughness of a
                      ground and scraped surface.

                      Jim
                      .

                      Sir John , Earl of Bligeport & Sudspumpwater. MBE [ Motor Bike Engineer ] Nottingham England.



                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by Teenage_Machinist

                        Scraping and toolmaking == NO! NOT PRECISE ENOUGH!
                        They're perfectly suitable where 0.0002 is not necessary which at home is quite a bit. I used mine for scraping and improved the surface of the work immensely. I've done side by side checks with my granite surface plate and the granite tile and the differences for my environment are not significant.

                        Given the cost of true surface plates today the only justification for using a tile is convenience - they're easy to put away, and abuse. You can beat the hell out of them and not feel bad.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          By a piece and test it. From my web site:

                          http://metalshopborealis.ca/laser/flattest.htm

                          If it doesn't make the grade it is still a handy work surface.
                          Free software for calculating bolt circles and similar: Click Here

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Not only that but they do not get burs from being beaten, in fact a good piece of tile may be better than the mill table.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by Teenage_Machinist
                              Not only that but they do not get burs from being beaten, in fact a good piece of tile may be better than the mill table.
                              They're the hot new thing on table saws and joiners, and probably router tables, soon enough. They're probably cheaper than casting iron for the same purpose.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X